Skip to content

FootballPreviews · Premier League ·

Manchester United vs Tottenham: after the Brighton collapse

Margus Sellin

Premier League · Matchday 6 · full time
Manchester United
Full time
1–1
Tottenham
Kick-off
Venue
Old Trafford, Manchester
Our call
Manchester United 2–1 Tottenham

Manchester United win. Logged 8 Oct, 07:30 UTC, never edited.

What happened

Manchester United 1–1 Tottenham. We said Manchester United win 2–1: Wrong result, 0 points.

  • Bryan Mbeumo put United ahead on 73', from Matheus Cunha's pass, and Dominic Solanke equalised on 90+2', set up by Sandro Tonali. We named Bruno Fernandes against Rodrigo Bentancur as the duel to watch, and said space could open for Mbeumo if Bentancur followed Fernandes. Mbeumo did score, but Fernandes neither scored nor assisted, and one United goal was not enough.
  • The shots were level at 12 shots to 12, United had 4 on target to 3, and Tottenham had 55% of the ball. Where we were wrong: we said United's scoring would be the difference at Old Trafford, and they managed one goal in 90 minutes. What we got right: Spurs scored once, as we expected, and we said that if United dropped points we would expect a draw rather than a Spurs win.
Before the match: our preview

In 30 seconds

  • Tottenham are bottom of the Premier League with 2 points from five games.
  • Bruno Fernandes has 4 goals in United's last ten games, and United have scored in 8 of their last 10.
  • United have been patchy too, but they keep scoring and Spurs rarely do. At Old Trafford that should be enough for a home win.

The story

Manchester United went out of the League Cup on Wed 16 Sep after leading Brighton 2–0 at Old Trafford and losing 3–2, three days after a 1–0 home defeat by Manchester City in the derby. A late Matheus Cunha goal rescued a 1–1 draw at Fulham on Sun 20 Sep, and United go into the game 12th with 5 points from five matches. Carrick took the blame after Brighton: "We had the game exactly where we wanted it and let it get away from us in a big way."

Roberto De Zerbi's problem is simpler to state and harder to fix. He kept Tottenham up after taking over in March, and this season they have not won a league game. Spurs are bottom with 2 points and have scored twice in five league matches, both in the 3–2 home defeat by Aston Villa on Sat 19 Sep, when Conor Gallagher came off the bench to score late and Jan Paul van Hecke headed in a second deep in stoppage time.

The table makes it a big afternoon for both. A win takes United to 8 points, level with Hull City and Newcastle. For Spurs, a defeat would be their fourth in six league games.

Bruno Fernandes plays behind the striker, and he will meet Rodrigo Bentancur in the space in front of the Spurs back four. That back four is without Pedro Porro, and its two Dutch centre-backs are coming back from knocks.

Form

Manchester United

One win in five, against Sabah in the Champions League.

Tottenham

No win since the 5–1 against Charlton in the League Cup on 26 Aug.

The games, with scores
Manchester United20 Sepat FulhamPLD 1–1
16 Sepv BrightonLCL 2–3
13 Sepv Manchester CityPLL 0–1
10 Sepv Sabah FAUCLW 4–0
6 Sepat EvertonPLD 2–2
Tottenham19 Sepv Aston VillaPLL 2–3
15 Sepat LiverpoolLCL 1–3
12 Sepv EvertonPLD 0–0
5 Sepat Nottingham ForestPLD 0–0
29 Augv NewcastlePLL 0–2

Latest first. Latest on the left. PL = Premier League, LC = League Cup, UCL = Champions League. OddsIntel match database, read 7 Oct 2026.

↑ Our call

Team news

Patrick Dorgu · Manchester Uniteda hamstring problem: forced off for Denmark against Wales and sent back to Carrington for tests. Luke Shaw, who started at Fulham, stays at left-back. (reported)Doubtful
Noussair Mazraoui · Manchester Unitedhurt in a collision for Morocco against Lesotho and left out of their next game. He was not in the last XI, so it thins the cover rather than the team. (reported)Doubtful
Benjamin Šeško · Manchester Uniteda shin problem kept him out at Fulham. Cunha led the line there and scored. (reported)Doubtful
Pedro Porro · Tottenhamforced off with a hamstring problem early in the Villa game on 19 Sep and pulled out of the Spain squad; reports put him out for about a month. De Zerbi needs a new right-back. (reported)Out
Jan Paul van Hecke · Tottenhamleft the Netherlands camp with a foot problem. Dutch reporting says it is not serious. (reported)Doubtful
Micky van de Ven · Tottenhamhurt his hand against Serbia on Sun 4 Oct. Netherlands coach Xavi Hernández called it ‘not a big problem’. (reported)Doubtful
Mikey Moore · Tottenhamon a season-long loan at 1. FC Köln. His 3 goals in the last ten are not available to De Zerbi. (reported)Out

Checked Wed 7 Oct 19:00 UTC: the Manchester Evening News (via Yahoo Sport), ESPN and AP for United; Sky Sports, AOL, GiveMeSport and bundesliga.com for Tottenham. Reported = not yet confirmed by the club. Line-ups: confirmed about an hour before kick-off; they go under Updates. We don't publish guessed XIs.

Two more Spurs scorers are missing from the last XI. Conor Gallagher, with 3 goals in Tottenham's last ten, was on the bench against Villa and scored after coming on; no injury has been reported. Ben Davies, with 2, did not start either, with Robertson at left-back, and the outlets we checked give no reason.

Both last XIs on a pitch

Tottenham 4-2-3-1 · v Aston Villa, 19 Sep

  1. Kinský
  2. Porrovan Heckevan de VenRobertson
  3. Bentancur (key battle)Tonali
  4. SávioM. FernandesMarmoush
  5. Solanke
  1. Cunha
  2. RashfordB. Fernandes (key battle)Mbeumo
  3. TielemansMainoo
  4. ShawMartínezMaguireDalot
  5. Lammens

Manchester United 4-2-3-1 · at Fulham, 20 Sep

Last XIs (United 20 Sep, Tottenham 19 Sep), not a guess at the next ones. OddsIntel match database, read 7 Oct 2026.

Who to watch

The duel to watch: Bruno Fernandes against Rodrigo Bentancur. Fernandes plays behind Cunha and drifts into the gap between the lines; Bentancur started in the two-man Spurs midfield against Villa. If Bentancur follows him, space opens for Bryan Mbeumo cutting in from the right. If he holds his position, Fernandes gets time to choose his pass or shoot.

Manchester United

Bryan Mbeumo

Started wide on the right of United's attacking three at Fulham.

3
goals, United's last 10

Tottenham

Dominic Solanke

Led the line against Villa. With Moore gone on loan, Spurs need goals from him.

1
goals, Tottenham's last 10

Goals in each side's last ten games, all competitions. OddsIntel match database, read 7 Oct 2026.

Head-to-head

United won the latest meeting 2–0 at Old Trafford in February. Spurs won three of the four before it, the 2025 Europa League final in Bilbao among them.

Manchester United v Tottenham 2–07 Feb 2026Premier League, Manchester✓ W
Tottenham v Manchester United 2–28 Nov 2025Premier League, London= D
Tottenham v Manchester United 1–021 May 2025Europa League final, Bilbao✕ L
All 5 meetings
Tottenham v Manchester United 1–016 Feb 2025Premier League, London✕ L
Tottenham v Manchester United 4–319 Dec 2024League Cup, London✕ L

Result for Manchester United. The last five meetings. OddsIntel match database, read 7 Oct 2026.

↑ Our call

Numbers that matter

Manchester UnitedTottenham

Goals scored, last five: Manchester United 9, Tottenham 3 (higher is better)

Three times as many. Spurs failed to score in three of those five games.

Goals conceded, last five · fewer is better: Manchester United 7, Tottenham 8 (lower is better)

Almost level: Spurs have let in one more.

Clean sheets, last ten: Manchester United 1, Tottenham 3 (higher is better)

The surprise: Spurs keep more, two of them in goalless league draws. United have kept one.

Last five or ten games each, all competitions, as labelled. OddsIntel match database, read 7 Oct 2026.

Our call, explained

We have United winning 2–1. Over ten games the two sides look closer than the table suggests: two wins each, and neither defence has been reliable. The difference is at the other end. United have scored in 8 of their last 10, and Fernandes, Mbeumo and Cunha share 9 goals in that run. Tottenham have lost Moore to a loan and an injured right-back, and may have to patch up the middle of their defence. United concede in almost every game, so we expect Spurs to score once.

Where this could go wrong. De Zerbi's side drew 0–0 twice in a row in September, and a patient, deep Spurs could frustrate a nervous Old Trafford. If United go behind, their September says they can come apart. De Zerbi could change his attack. If he does, and the Dutch centre-backs are fit, Spurs are better than the bottom of the table says. If United do drop points, we would expect a draw rather than a Spurs win.

Updates

10 Oct, 20:30 CEST

Full time: Manchester United 1–1 Tottenham (Mbeumo 73'; Solanke 90+2'). Our 2–1 call: wrong result. See What happened.

Next: nothing further; this match is finished.

Data note: results, scorers, the table and line-ups from our database, read 7 Oct 18:10 UTC; team news and match details from Sky Sports, the Manchester Evening News, ESPN, AP, Yahoo Sport, AOL, GiveMeSport and bundesliga.com.

Our call was timestamped by an independent service before kick-off, Thu 8 Oct, 09:40 UTC.

How the timestamp works

Timestamped before kick-off by an independent service (DigiCert, RFC 3161), Thu 8 Oct, 09:40 UTC. The call file is the exact version that was timestamped. The file with our call and its timestamp token: call file · timestamp. Its fingerprint (sha256):

a04f2406afa1b2606282678907bf1526f9b93f7c22998d7c05915f56ee14a6d3

Our calls so far

Every call
calls right
39/66
home win every time
30/66
Small sample: 66 games

Keep reading