- Kick-off
- Venue
- The Hawthorns, West Bromwich
A draw. Logged 9 Oct, 07:30 UTC, never edited.
What happened
West Brom 0–1 Birmingham. We said a draw, 1–1: Wrong result, 0 points.
- August Priske scored the only goal, a penalty on 41'. We picked Jimmy-Jay Morgan against Phil Neumann as the duel to watch, and Morgan did not score: West Brom did not score at all. We said Morgan would decide whether Albion's unbeaten home league record survived. It did not.
- Birmingham had 15 shots to 14 and 7 on target to 2, while West Brom had 54% of the ball. Where we were wrong: we expected West Brom to score at home and Birmingham to draw again, and instead Birmingham won and kept a clean sheet. What we got right: Birmingham found a goal, as they do in most games. We named an Albion win as the likelier miss, and it was Birmingham who won.
Before the match: our preview
In 30 seconds
- West Brom are fifth and unbeaten at the Hawthorns in the league: two wins and two draws.
- Birmingham have won only two of their eight Championship games, and the last two derbies finished level.
- Albion's home record ends up intact, but they do not win this one.
The story
James Morrison has made a steady start to his first full season as West Brom head coach. He took the job for good in April after Eric Ramsay's short spell, and eight games into this one Albion are fifth with 14 points. Nobody has beaten them at the Hawthorns in the league: they beat Burnley and Watford and drew with QPR and Charlton. Their last game before the international break, though, was a 1–0 defeat at Wolves on Sun 20 Sep, settled by a defensive mistake. "You can't gift goals like that," Morrison said afterwards.
Chris Davies's Birmingham are tenth with 11 points and have a habit. They have drawn five of their eight league games, four of them at St Andrew's, and both of their wins came away, at Derby and Wrexham. They score in most games, but they also let goals in: Middlesbrough, Wolves and Bristol City all scored twice against them.
The question for Morrison is Jimmy-Jay Morgan. The striker has 5 of West Brom's 16 goals in their last ten games, and he pulled out of England Under-20 duty with a knock. Callum Styles left the Hungary squad for the same reason. Albion's medical staff say they hope both will be back in contention.
A win would take Albion to 17 points, level with the leaders Swansea before the rest of the round is played. A Birmingham win would lift them to 14, level with Albion. This game is decided by whether Morgan can get the better of Phil Neumann and the Birmingham centre-backs.
Form
Four goals in these five, never more than one in a game.
Three draws in five, all at home.
The games, with scores
| West Brom | 20 Sep | at WolvesCH | L 0–1 |
| 12 Sep | v QPRCH | D 1–1 | |
| 9 Sep | at DerbyCH | W 1–0 | |
| 5 Sep | v WatfordCH | W 1–0 | |
| 2 Sep | v CharltonCH | D 1–1 | |
| Birmingham | 19 Sep | v MiddlesbroughCH | D 2–2 |
| 12 Sep | at DerbyCH | W 2–1 | |
| 9 Sep | at NorwichCH | L 1–2 | |
| 6 Sep | v WolvesCH | D 2–2 | |
| 1 Sep | v SouthamptonCH | D 1–1 |
Latest first. Latest on the left. CH = Championship. OddsIntel match database, read 8 Oct 2026.
Team news
Checked Thu 8 Oct 15:10 UTC: our injury data, the Express & Star and Shropshire Star, BirminghamWorld, Sky Sports, bcfc.com and Football League World. Reported = not yet confirmed by the club. Line-ups: confirmed about an hour before kick-off; they go under Updates. We don't publish guessed XIs.
All of West Brom's top scorers started at Wolves. Birmingham's scorers in their last ten are spread thin: Carlos Vicente, Phil Neumann, August Priske and Gray have 2 each. Priske did not start the 2–2 with Middlesbrough on Sat 19 Sep, and the outlets we checked give no injury or reason for it.
Starting line-ups from each side's last game, not a guess at the next ones. West Brom at Wolves (20 Sep): O'Leary; Styles, Phillips, Campbell, Townsend; Whitwell, Molumby, Diakité, Price; Heggebø, Morgan. Birmingham against Middlesbrough (19 Sep, 4-2-3-1): Beadle; Osayi-Samuel, Neumann, Klarer, Cochrane; Iwata, Solís; Vicente, Stansfield, Millar; Vázquez.
Who to watch
The duel to watch: Jimmy-Jay Morgan against Phil Neumann. Morgan, Albion's top scorer, plays up front alongside Aune Heggebø. Neumann, in the middle of Birmingham's back four, is also one of their scorers, with 2 goals in their last ten. If Morgan is fit, he tests Neumann, and Isaac Price arrives from midfield behind him.
West Brom
Jimmy-Jay Morgan
Albion's top scorer, if the knock has cleared.
- 5
- goals, West Brom's last 10
West Brom
Isaac Price
Arrives late from midfield, Albion's second scorer.
- 4
- goals, West Brom's last 10
Birmingham
Carlos Vicente
Starts wide in the three behind the striker.
- 2
- goals, Birmingham's last 10
Goals in each side's last ten games, all competitions. OddsIntel match database, read 8 Oct 2026.
Head-to-head
The last two league meetings were draws, 1–1 at the Hawthorns and 0–0 at St Andrew's. The five include a pre-season friendly in 2024.
All 5 meetings
Result for West Brom. The last five meetings, friendlies included. OddsIntel match database, read 8 Oct 2026.
Numbers that matter
Goals scored, last ten: West Brom 16, Birmingham 14 (higher is better)
Close. Birmingham's total includes their one goal in a 1–6 home League Cup defeat by Brentford.
Goals conceded, last ten · fewer is better: West Brom 12, Birmingham 17 (lower is better)
Albion concede fewer, though six of Birmingham's 17 came in one League Cup game against Brentford.
Draws, last ten · fewer is better: West Brom 2, Birmingham 5 (lower is better)
The surprise: Birmingham have drawn as many as they have won and lost put together.
Last ten games each, all competitions (two League Cup games each). OddsIntel match database, read 8 Oct 2026.
Our call, explained
We have it 1–1. Albion have not scored more than once in any of their last five, and Birmingham find a goal in most games. Davies's side, missing Gray, Bird and Gardner-Hickman, are unlikely to beat a side that has conceded 12 in ten. Morgan carries Albion's goals, and a striker coming back from a knock is a reason to expect one goal, not two.
Where this could go wrong. A fully fit Morgan with Price arriving behind him could give West Brom a second goal against a Birmingham defence that let in two each to Middlesbrough, Norwich and Wolves in September. Birmingham could also win it: they scored twice at Derby and Wrexham, and Albion lost at Wolves to one mistake. Of the two, an Albion win is the likelier miss.
Updates
10 Oct, 17:15 CEST
Full time: West Brom 0–1 Birmingham (Priske 41', penalty). Our 1–1 call: wrong result. See What happened.
Next: nothing further; this match is finished.
Data note: results, scorers, the table, injuries and line-ups from our database, read 8 Oct 12:10 UTC; team news and match details from the Express & Star, Shropshire Star, BirminghamWorld, Sky Sports, bcfc.com, Football League World and PA.
Our call was timestamped by an independent service before kick-off, Fri 9 Oct, 07:20 UTC.
How the timestamp works
Timestamped before kick-off by an independent service (DigiCert, RFC 3161), Fri 9 Oct, 07:20 UTC. The call file is the exact version that was timestamped. The file with our call and its timestamp token: call file · timestamp. Its fingerprint (sha256):
1cbed4039500a35cd091b42ef7abd5ecbb259b3644f2aa7039f8cb3ed92b6f49
Our calls so far
- calls right
- 39/66
- home win every time
- 30/66