The Price Check · #4
NerdyTips review: 66.6% claimed wins, −3.4% at its own odds
How accurate is NerdyTips? We graded its best tip for every match over 30 days against its printed odds and the closing odds.
Loses
Lost money in our test
−4.4%
95% range −6.9% to −2.1%. Grade C: we saw its picks only after the games.
Our verdict
Stake 100 euro on every pick and you got 95.6 euro back.
Made money in our test?
Loses. The whole 95% range is below zero.
−4.4% at the odds it showed. 95% range −6.9% to −2.1%.
Could you have got these odds?
Maybe. Odds were read after the games, so we cannot prove you could have bet them.
As read on 10 Nov. Final price: −4.5% (capture time unknown)
Big enough test?
Yes. 30 days, 3,138 picks.
We ask 30+ days and 300+ picks.
Rules were written on 23 Oct 2026, before the picks were read.
DisclosureIn this articleHow we checked
This review is for anyone deciding whether to follow NerdyTips.
€10 on each Over/Under 2.5 tip in 30 days: −€1,372 at its prices (past results, illustration only).
What is NerdyTips? Price, tiers and claims
In short: a model-based predictions site that publishes win rates, not returns. It says so itself.
NerdyTipssells "AI football predictions" from a model it calls NT Apex: for each match a result tip, a goals line, both teams to score and a best tip, each with printed odds and a trust score out of 10. It is run by KickOff Ventures LLC (Delaware, the name in its footer). Free: 6 tips a day, no account. Paid plans run from €9.99 for one month to €35.99 for six, with a 3-day money-back guarantee. We tested the tips it shows to everyone after full time, which include the paid ones.
We tested one pick per match, its best tip, because that is the tip its own win-rate claim measures. Its other three tips per match are not tested. These are its claims:
| NerdyTips says | What we measured |
|---|---|
| “66.6% of the 287,254 matches NT Apex has predicted since May 2021 finished as forecast.” | Over/Under 2.5 goals, 10 Oct to 8 Nov 2026: 3,138 picks returned −4.4% at its own odds (95% range −6.9% to −2.1%); the 2,729 we graded ourselves, −3.0% (95% range −5.3% to −0.9%). |
| “Since the start of 2026 we have published 1,707 banker picks and 1,249 came in, a 73% win rate” | We can only test what it publishes: 12,139 picks in our window. Alerts it left out of the record are not visible to us. |
| “Our track record shows win rates, not profit or return figures.” | Over/Under 2.5 goals, 10 Oct to 8 Nov 2026: 3,138 picks returned −4.4% at its own odds (95% range −6.9% to −2.1%); the 2,729 we graded ourselves, −3.0% (95% range −5.3% to −0.9%). |
| “Correct tips divided by settled tips.” | Its result agrees with ours on 100.0% of 2,726 picks. |
- “66.6% of the 287,254 matches NT Apex has predicted since May 2021 finished as forecast.”What we measured: Over/Under 2.5 goals, 10 Oct to 8 Nov 2026: 3,138 picks returned −4.4% at its own odds (95% range −6.9% to −2.1%); the 2,729 we graded ourselves, −3.0% (95% range −5.3% to −0.9%).
- “Since the start of 2026 we have published 1,707 banker picks and 1,249 came in, a 73% win rate”What we measured: We can only test what it publishes: 12,139 picks in our window. Alerts it left out of the record are not visible to us.
- “Our track record shows win rates, not profit or return figures.”What we measured: Over/Under 2.5 goals, 10 Oct to 8 Nov 2026: 3,138 picks returned −4.4% at its own odds (95% range −6.9% to −2.1%); the 2,729 we graded ourselves, −3.0% (95% range −5.3% to −0.9%).
- “Correct tips divided by settled tips.”What we measured: Its result agrees with ours on 100.0% of 2,726 picks.
“66.6% of the 287,254 matches NT Apex has predicted since May 2021 finished as forecast.”
How we checked NerdyTips's picks
Every pick on NerdyTips's public results pages, 10 Oct to 8 Nov 2026: 11,402 graded picks in 6 markets, checked against the scores and closing odds we record.
The marks at the top of this page:
YesMaybeNoToo early
The final price is Pinnacle's closing price, the last price before kick-off. The strip describes our test, in our sample: it is not betting advice.
The method in full
- What we collected
- Every pick on NerdyTips's public results pages in the window, with the odds printed beside it and its result (12,139 rows read)
- Period
- 10 Oct to 8 Nov 2026 (30 days, by kick-off date)
- Sample
- 11,402 graded picks in 6 markets; 1,492 picks we could not match to our fixtures (mostly leagues we do not carry). In Match result and Double chance and Over/Under 1.5 goals and Over/Under 2.5 goals and Over/Under 3.5 goals and Both teams to score they count, graded by NerdyTips's own result, because its results agree with ours on 100% of the picks we can check in each (our rule: at least 97%); elsewhere they are excluded; 417 picks in markets we could not test are counted and excluded; 80 picks whose printed score differs from the game we matched (mostly a youth or reserve side with the same club names, or a cup tie where one of the two scores includes extra time) are treated as unmatched, never graded with the wrong game
- Prices
- the odds NerdyTips prints next to each tip (no bookmaker named). We test ONE pick per match, the site's 'best tip' (the tip its own 66.6 % claim measures, per its FAQ); its other three tips per match are stored (extra.other_tips) but not tested. The price of the picked outcome is graded; as the second basis, the sharp close: the sharp closing line, with its margin removed
- Proof grade
- C: read after the fact from its history pages
- Pre-committed
- Site, window, markets and tests logged 23 Oct 2026, before the audit ran
NerdyTips's history was read after the matches from its results pages; we did not capture it live, so the pages could have changed before we read them. Paid tiers were not tested. Break-even is computed pick by pick (the average of 1 ÷ odds). Every 95% range comes from a bootstrap that resamples whole days, because picks on the same day are linked. Voids and pushes return the stake and count as no bet; results are our fixture result over 90 minutes plus stoppage time. Sharp closing prices cover only part of Match result (1,791 of 2,135), Double chance (2,550 of 3,058), Over/Under 1.5 goals (598 of 1,025), Over/Under 2.5 goals (2,334 of 3,138), Over/Under 3.5 goals (786 of 1,625). No sharp closing price for Both teams to score. The window is 30 days (10 Oct to 8 Nov 2026). Its tips for upcoming matches are locked except about six a day, so only 1.6% of the 9,905 tips we matched to a fixture were on its pages before kick-off. For 8,590 of them we hold a read of that day's page from before kick-off that did not list the tip, and 110 changed after kick-off. Double chance and both-teams-to-score have no price check against the books we record. Both teams to score has no sharp close either, so it is left out of the sharp-close figures. The full method is on our methodology page.
How the CLV table is computed. Mean CLV = the expected return at the fair close. CLV per pick = its odds × the sharp close's fair probability − 1 (margin removed by the Shin method for three outcomes, the power method for two). The share of picks beating the fair close is descriptive only: Match result 26.8%; Double chance 9.3%; Over/Under 1.5 goals 13.7%; Over/Under 2.5 goals 10.7%; Over/Under 3.5 goals 12.2%.
How the no-analysis rule is compared. Returns at the sharp close. Caveat: the rule chooses with kick-off prices, so it shows what a win rate is made of, not a strategy, and nobody has kick-off prices when a tip is published.
How our own lines are computed. Every settled pre-match pick of every bot on /performance, at the published price; the subset posted to our public Telegram channel before kick-off. Flat stake, break-even per pick, CLV against the de-vigged sharp close by the same method as above. 99.3% of the /performance picks were sealed before kick-off.
How the best price is found. Best price = the highest price any of the bookmakers we record offered on the same pick in the 48 hours before kick-off (median 9 books recorded per fixture, so where it is 1 this check is weak; exchanges excluded), with a 2% tolerance.
Unmatched picks and thin markets. Between 11% and 14% of the tips in each market could not be matched to our fixtures; they count here, graded by its own result column, because that column agrees with the scores we record on 100.0% of the 9,905 picks we could check across the six markets. Both teams to score has 421 picks, which is thin: its 95% range (−7.6% to +8.5%) includes both a loss and a win.
NerdyTips results at its own odds
| Market | Picks | Win rate | Avg odds | Needed to break even | Return at its odds | 95% range | At the sharp close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Match resultall picks | 2,135 | 65.6% | 1.55 | 65.8% | −0.5% | −3.5% to +2.6% | −1.8%1,791 of 2,135 picks |
| of which matched to our fixtures | 1,841 | 66.2% | 1.56 | 65.6% | +0.6% | −2.9% to +4.0% | as above |
| Double chanceall picks | 3,058 | 69.6% | 1.39 | 73.2% | −5.2% | −7.3% to −3.1% | −0.0%2,550 of 3,058 picks |
| of which matched to our fixtures | 2,671 | 70.2% | 1.39 | 73.2% | −4.5% | −6.6% to −2.5% | as above |
| Over/Under 1.5 goalsall picks | 1,025 | 74.6% | 1.31 | 76.9% | −2.9% | −6.4% to +0.5% | −4.5%598 of 1,025 picks |
| of which matched to our fixtures | 906 | 75.3% | 1.31 | 76.9% | −2.0% | −5.9% to +1.9% | as above |
| Over/Under 2.5 goalsall picks | 3,138 | 63.9% | 1.51 | 66.8% | −4.4% | −6.9% to −2.1% | −4.5%2,334 of 3,138 picks |
| of which matched to our fixtures | 2,729 | 64.7% | 1.51 | 66.8% | −3.0% | −5.3% to −0.9% | as above |
| Over/Under 3.5 goalsall picks | 1,625 | 70.8% | 1.37 | 73.4% | −3.2% | −5.9% to −0.5% | −3.0%786 of 1,625 picks |
| of which matched to our fixtures | 1,412 | 71.0% | 1.37 | 73.3% | −3.0% | −6.3% to +0.4% | as above |
| Both teams to scoreall picks | 421 | 69.1% | 1.48 | 68.3% | +1.5% | −7.6% to +8.5% | no sharp close |
| of which matched to our fixtures | 358 | 69.3% | 1.48 | 68.4% | +1.3% | −8.8% to +8.7% | as above |
- Over/Under 2.5 goals−4.4%Loses3,138 picks, range −6.9% to −2.1%
- Double chance−5.2%Loses3,058 picks, range −7.3% to −3.1%
- Match result−0.5%Maybe2,135 picks, range −3.5% to +2.6%
Show 3 more markets
- Over/Under 3.5 goals−3.2%Loses1,625 picks, range −5.9% to −0.5%
- Over/Under 1.5 goals−2.9%Maybe1,025 picks, range −6.4% to +0.5%
- Both teams to score+1.5%Maybe421 picks, range −7.6% to +8.5%
Source: NerdyTips results pages, graded by us. Rows under 300 picks greyed.
Match result: −€99 after 30 days at €10 a pick.
| Match result | −€99 | |
| Double chance | −€1,599 | |
| Over/Under 1.5 goals | −€299 | |
| Over/Under 2.5 goals | −€1,372 | |
| Over/Under 3.5 goals | −€526 | |
| Both teams to score | €61 |
Source: NerdyTips results pages, graded by us. Rows under 300 picks greyed.
Did NerdyTips beat the closing odds?
NerdyTips's odds: capture time unknown, read after the matches (proof grade C). A tipster who beats the close is finding prices; one who doesn't is following them.
| Market | Picks matched to a sharp close | Mean CLV | 95% range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Match result | 1,791 | −2.6% | −2.9% to −2.4% |
| Double chance | 2,550 | −4.7% | −4.9% to −4.5% |
| Over/Under 1.5 goals | 598 | −2.4% | −2.7% to −2.1% |
| Over/Under 2.5 goals | 2,334 | −4.4% | −4.7% to −4.2% |
| Over/Under 3.5 goals | 786 | −3.5% | −3.9% to −3.2% |
| Both teams to scoretoo few to read | 0 | no sharp close | n/a |
| Busy markets together | 8,059 | −3.9% | −4.0% to −3.8% |
- Match result−2.6%Loses1,791 picks, range −2.9% to −2.4%
- Double chance−4.7%Loses2,550 picks, range −4.9% to −4.5%
- Over/Under 1.5 goals−2.4%Loses598 picks, range −2.7% to −2.1%
- Over/Under 2.5 goals−4.4%Loses2,334 picks, range −4.7% to −4.2%
- Over/Under 3.5 goals−3.5%Loses786 picks, range −3.9% to −3.2%
- Busy markets together−3.9%Loses8,059 picks, range −4.0% to −3.8%
Source: NerdyTips results pages, graded by us. Rows under 300 picks greyed. Method: see “The method in full” above.
Could you get its printed price?
| Market | Picks checked | Within the tolerance of the best price offered | More than 1.5× every book | Median against the best price | Against its reference book |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Match result | 2,045 | 96.9% | 0.0% | −3.3% | n/a |
| Over/Under 1.5 goals | 949 | 97.4% | 0.0% | −0.9% | n/a |
| Over/Under 2.5 goals | 2,953 | 97.9% | 0.0% | −2.8% | n/a |
| Over/Under 3.5 goals | 1,485 | 98.2% | 0.0% | −1.6% | n/a |
- Match result96.9%2,045 picks, 3.3% under the best price
- Over/Under 1.5 goals97.4%949 picks, 0.9% under the best price
- Over/Under 2.5 goals97.9%2,953 picks, 2.8% under the best price
- Over/Under 3.5 goals98.2%1,485 picks, 1.6% under the best price
Best price: see “The method in full” above.
Is it skill? NerdyTips against a no-analysis rule
On each day NerdyTips published picks, the rule takes the same number of picks, choosing whichever outcome the sharp closing odds made most likely. No form, no team news, no model. Both sides are priced at the sharp close, so each side counts only the picks with a sharp closing price, and the two counts can differ.
| Market | Its picks | Its win rate | Its odds | Its return | Rule picks | Rule win rate | Rule odds | Rule return |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Match result | 1,679 | 66.3% | 1.53 | −1.4% | 725 | 74.3% | 1.35 | −1.0% |
| Double chance | 2,408 | 70.4% | 1.46 | +0.4% | 1,102 | 87.8% | 1.16 | +1.7% |
| Over/Under 1.5 goals | 571 | 73.0% | 1.32 | −3.9% | 248 | 87.5% | 1.14 | −0.6%too few to read |
| Over/Under 2.5 goals | 2,204 | 62.8% | 1.54 | −3.8% | 1,002 | 65.9% | 1.43 | −6.3% |
| Over/Under 3.5 goals | 746 | 68.0% | 1.43 | −3.7% | 330 | 79.4% | 1.25 | −1.0% |
- Match result−1.4%−1.0%Its picks: 1,679 · Rule picks: 725 · Its win rate: 66.3% · Rule win rate: 74.3% · Its odds: 1.53 · Rule odds: 1.35
- Double chance+0.4%+1.7%Its picks: 2,408 · Rule picks: 1,102 · Its win rate: 70.4% · Rule win rate: 87.8% · Its odds: 1.46 · Rule odds: 1.16
- Over/Under 1.5 goals−3.9%−0.6%too few to readIts picks: 571 · Rule picks: 248 · Its win rate: 73.0% · Rule win rate: 87.5% · Its odds: 1.32 · Rule odds: 1.14
- Over/Under 2.5 goals−3.8%−6.3%Its picks: 2,204 · Rule picks: 1,002 · Its win rate: 62.8% · Rule win rate: 65.9% · Its odds: 1.54 · Rule odds: 1.43
- Over/Under 3.5 goals−3.7%−1.0%Its picks: 746 · Rule picks: 330 · Its win rate: 68.0% · Rule win rate: 79.4% · Its odds: 1.43 · Rule odds: 1.25
Returns at the sharp close, on picks with a sharp closing price. Caveat and method: see “The method in full” above.
One real day of NerdyTips picks
| Match | League | Pick | Odds | Sharp close | Score | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Borussia Dortmund v Eintracht Frankfurt | Bundesliga (Germany) | Match result: 1 | 1.45 | 1.41 | 1–0 | Won |
| RB Leipzig v Elversberg | Bundesliga (Germany) | Match result: 1 | 1.56 | 1.54 | 4–0 | Won |
| FC Augsburg v Union Berlin | Bundesliga (Germany) | Double chance: 1X | 1.24 | 1.26 | 1–1 | Won |
| SC Paderborn 07 v Hamburger SV | Bundesliga (Germany) | Double chance: 1X | 1.39 | 1.41 | 1–0 | Won |
| 1. FC Koln v FC Schalke 04 | Bundesliga (Germany) | Double chance: 1X | 1.39 | 1.43 | 0–0 | Won |
| FSV Mainz 05 v Werder Bremen | Bundesliga (Germany) | Over/Under 2.5 goals: O2.5 | 1.52 | 1.53 | 2–3 | Won |
- Borussia Dortmund v Eintracht FrankfurtWonLeague: Bundesliga (Germany) · Pick: Match result: 1 · Odds: 1.45 · Sharp close: 1.41 · Score: 1–0
- RB Leipzig v ElversbergWonLeague: Bundesliga (Germany) · Pick: Match result: 1 · Odds: 1.56 · Sharp close: 1.54 · Score: 4–0
- FC Augsburg v Union BerlinWonLeague: Bundesliga (Germany) · Pick: Double chance: 1X · Odds: 1.24 · Sharp close: 1.26 · Score: 1–1
- SC Paderborn 07 v Hamburger SVWonLeague: Bundesliga (Germany) · Pick: Double chance: 1X · Odds: 1.39 · Sharp close: 1.41 · Score: 1–0
- 1. FC Koln v FC Schalke 04WonLeague: Bundesliga (Germany) · Pick: Double chance: 1X · Odds: 1.39 · Sharp close: 1.43 · Score: 0–0
- FSV Mainz 05 v Werder BremenWonLeague: Bundesliga (Germany) · Pick: Over/Under 2.5 goals: O2.5 · Odds: 1.52 · Sharp close: 1.53 · Score: 2–3
The full card that day held 898 graded picks, 610 of them won. Source: NerdyTips results.
NerdyTips scorecard: who it's for
Shows the odds for every pick
YesOdds printed beside 100.0% of the picks we graded, in every tested market.
Shows profit or loss
NoProfitable at its own odds
MixedSix markets, judged at its printed odds with the range widened for six markets (both teams to score is thin at 421 picks). Over/Under 2.5 returned −4.4% (95% range −6.9% to −2.1%); double chance −5.2% (95% range −7.3% to −3.1%). Odds were read after the matches (grade C).
Beats the closing odds
UnreliableNerdyTips's odds were read after the matches (proof grade C), so the capture time is unknown and this row cannot pass. The CLV table above is printed for reference only.
Beats a no-analysis rule
MixedReturn against the no-analysis rule at the same prices, busy markets.
Published record matches its picks
YesMatch result: its result column 66.2% wins, our grading 66.2% (all 1,840 picks agree); Double chance: its result column 70.1% wins, our grading 70.1% (all 2,666 picks agree); Over/Under 1.5 goals: its result column 75.4% wins, our grading 75.4% (all 905 picks agree); Over/Under 2.5 goals: its result column 64.7% wins, our grading 64.7% (all 2,726 picks agree); Over/Under 3.5 goals: its result column 70.9% wins, our grading 70.9% (all 1,410 picks agree); Both teams to score: its result column 69.3% wins, our grading 69.3% (all 358 picks agree). Verdict uses busy markets only.
Proof grade
Grade Cread after the fact from its history pages
What it does well
- It names its operator, shows odds beside every tip and says plainly that its record is win rates, not profit.
- Its own won or lost marks matched our grading on 100.0% of the 9,905 picks we could check.
- Its printed 1X2 odds were no more than 2% above the best price we hold on 96.9% of 2,045 picks (the median was 3.3% below the best).
Who it's for: Readers who want a free daily list of model tips and understand that a high win rate is not a profit.
Who should skip it: Anyone expecting the tips to pay at the odds it prints: in our test, double chance and Over/Under 2.5 lost, with 95% ranges below zero even after the widening for six markets.
Is NerdyTips legit? Our verdict
Is NerdyTips legit? It is a real site with a named operator, and its won or lost marks matched ours on all 9,905 picks we could check.
−3.4% at its printed odds (11,402 tips, 30 days); −2.3% at the sharp close. The no-analysis rule (a benchmark, not a strategy) beat the site in four of the five markets with a baseline; ranges overlap, so this shows no sign of skill, which is not proof there is none.
Treat it as a free list of likely winners, not a way to make money; check other books before staking.
Our own picks, same test
The same window and the same columns, for two lines of ours: every settled pre-match pick of every bot on /performance at the price we published, and the subset posted to our public Telegram channel before kick-off. Our picks are in different markets at different odds, so this compares what a reader of each got, not two models on the same games.
Ours, same window: +4.8% (1,947, all) and +10.7% (726, Telegram).
| Line | Proof | Picks | Win rate | Avg odds | Break-even | Return | 95% range | At the sharp close | CLV |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Every pick on /performance | C | 1,947 | 54.3% | 2.03 | 51.9% | +4.8% | +0.9% to +8.7% | +0.0% | +2.4% |
| Posted to Telegram before kick-off | B | 726 | 57.6% | 1.99 | 52.6% | +10.7% | +5.7% to +15.6% | +5.3% | +1.8% |
- Every pick on /performance+4.8%Proof: C · Picks: 1,947 · Win rate: 54.3% · Avg odds: 2.03 · Break-even: 51.9% · 95% range: +0.9% to +8.7% · At the sharp close: +0.0% · CLV: +2.4%
- Posted to Telegram before kick-off+10.7%Proof: B · Picks: 726 · Win rate: 57.6% · Avg odds: 1.99 · Break-even: 52.6% · 95% range: +5.7% to +15.6% · At the sharp close: +5.3% · CLV: +1.8%
Flat stake; method: see “The method in full” above.
How to check any tipster in 30 seconds
- 1
Ask for the odds
No odds, no verdict. A win rate on its own can't be checked.
- 2
Work out the break-even
1 ÷ odds for each pick, then the average. At odds of 1.25 you need to win 80% of the time. Is the win rate above it?
- 3
Check the sample
A few hundred picks prove little. Thousands start to.
- 4
Check the price you would get
Quoted odds you can't find at your own bookmaker don't count.
- 5
Check it against the close
Did the picks get better odds than the market settled on at kick-off? That is the sign of finding prices, not following them.
NerdyTips FAQ
FAQ (6)
Is NerdyTips legit?
Is NerdyTips a scam?
What are NerdyTips's real results?
Is NerdyTips's paid tier worth it?
How did we measure this?
How accurate are NerdyTips predictions?
Sources and archived copies
Show the sources
- 1.NerdyTips: homepage: read 23 Oct and 2 Nov 2026; plans, free tips per day, its win-rate claims and the operator in the footer · archived copy of NerdyTips: homepage (opens in new tab)
- 2.NerdyTips: progress: read 23 Oct 2026; its record definition (correct tips divided by settled tips) · archived copy of NerdyTips: progress (opens in new tab)
- 3.Ledger file: every number on this page: generated 10 Nov 2026
When we read these pages
Both pages read on 23 Oct 2026 (the homepage again on 2 Nov; not re-read for the 10 Nov re-check); each archived copy is a Wayback Machine snapshot taken 2 November 2026, so it shows the page on that day, not on the day we first read it. archive.ph was not used.
Updates, corrections and right of reply
Published 2 Nov 2026 on a 24-day window (10 Oct to 2 Nov): 9,161 tips, −3.5% at its own odds, −2.7% at the sharp close. We did not contact NerdyTips before publishing. It is welcome to respond; any reply will be published here in full. Re-checked 10 Nov 2026 on the full 30-day window (10 Oct to 8 Nov): 11,402 tips, −3.4% at its own odds, −2.3% at the sharp close. Same grade (C), same verdict; the shorter-window caveat is gone. Spot an error? Tell us in our Telegram channel and we will correct it and note the change here.
The Price Check #4 · More from The Price Check →