Methodology
How the numbers are made
In short
- We pick only when a bookmaker pays more than the outcome's real chance is worth.
- Every active-strategy pick counts, losses too.
- Sealed before kick-off since 28 Sept.
Some very high-edge picks are never posted, so they stay out of the headline
How a pick is made
Fair price = what a bet is really worth: the sharpest bookmaker’s price with its cut (margin) removed. A pick beats it.
Every bookmaker builds a margin into its odds. Remove it from a sharp bookmaker’s price and you get a fair price. A pick is a price somewhere in the market that pays more than that. Each pick on /picks says where its fair price came from:
- Sharp line — from the sharpest bookmaker. We publish when another bookmaker pays at least 3% more than that fair price, at odds up to 4.00. No model involved.
- Consensus — from several bookmakers agreeing, margins removed, where no single line is sharp enough. The label says how many.
A sharp or consensus edge is an expected return (+3% = 3% above break-even). Each pick also shows a break-even price, the lowest odds at which it is still worth taking. Odds move after a pick is posted, so check yours against it.
Testing and Active
Only Active strategies post picks and count in the headline. Testing ones keep their own record.
A strategy is one rule for finding picks. We have tested well over a hundred and retired most.
- Experimental / Testing — not published (only Active strategies post). A Testing strategy keeps its own record on /performance, outside the headline, and becomes Active after 50 settled picks that beat the sharp closing line on average.
- Active — its picks go to /picks and the Telegram channel (on Telegram, at most one per market per match) and count in the headline.
- VIP — a few strategies post only to the paid VIP channel, sealed like every other pick, each with its own record, not in the headline. Counted at the best price we found when we posted it. Prices move; check yours before you bet. VIP record
- Retired — stopped. Nothing is deleted: the record stays on /performance, losers included.
Which picks count
A pick counts if its strategy was Active when it was made. It stays counted for good.
A pick logged after the match started never counts, and neither does one we took out after a price re-check (each is listed on the corrections page). Pausing or retiring a strategy never removes its picks, and picks made while it was Testing never count, even after promotion. We show the all-time record (every counted pick, retired strategies included) and the current line-up(the same rule over today's Active strategies).
Three more rules. A pick above a strategy's edge ceiling (those tested worse) is left out of the headline, because no reader could have followed it, but still counts on the strategy’s own row. A strategy's record is not restarted when its rule changes; /performance says when it spans several versions. And a pick is graded at the best price available when it was made, unless that price was over 1.25× the sharpest bookmaker’s and no other bookmaker came within 5% of it; then it is graded at the best price another bookmaker really offered. We judge this only when at least three other independent bookmakers were quoting; otherwise the pick counts and is marked not price-checkable. A bookmaker quoting the price at our next snapshot (up to 35 minutes later, since 4 October 2026) confirms it; the pick's own bookmaker never does. Each pick stores the check version that judged it.
Every rule change is dated, with its effect on the figures, on the corrections page.
Did we beat the final price? (closing line value)
A few hundred results are mostly luck. Beating the final pre-kick-off price is the earlier signal.
Sharp markets move toward the right price as a match approaches, so a bettor who keeps getting better odds than the final price (the closing line) is usually right about value, whatever the next ten results say. That gap is closing line value (CLV).
Which CLV comes first. The CLV we show first, on /picks and /performance, is against the sharp closing line: the sharpest bookmaker’s closing price with its margin removed, or a consensus of five or more bookmakers where it has none. /picks also shows “vs book close” (against that bookmaker’s own close, margin included); it reads low by design for picks that exist because a bookmaker was slow to move, so it is a check, not the verdict. A close only counts if fresh: if the sharpest bookmaker’s last price was over two hours stale while others moved, we use the exchange’s close or an adjusted price, or give no sharp closing value.
Stake: computed at €10, shown at yours
Computed at a flat €10, shown at €25. Only the money figures change with the stake.
Every figure is computed at €10 flat per pick at the price available when the pick was made, so anyone can re-derive it from the public ledger. The pages let you view it at the stake you would bet (€5–€250; they open at €25). That only rescales the money figures; ROI, CLV, hit rate and pick counts are the same at every stake. See the full record.
How we compare with other tipsters
Same dates, same markets, settled picks only, the same flat stake on both sides.
We keep only what both sides cover (same dates, same markets, settled picks) and settle both at the same flat stake, so a comparison row counts fewer picks than our headline. Where a tipster’s own figures use prices no bookmaker we track offered, we show its claim next to its picks re-settled at the best real closing price. Every matched pick is in the public ledger; our reviews go through tipsters one by one.
We run the same test on tipster sites: The Price Check
Checking a pick yourself
Since 28 September every pick is sealed before kick-off. Four checks, each proving something different.
- Before kick-off: the seal. Each batch of new picks becomes a short code that changes if one character changes, signed by an independent timestamp authority (DigiCert, its own clock). After kick-off the pick and seal are published; check them on the verify page. It covers every pick, posted or not, since 28 September 2026.
- Before kick-off: Telegram. Many picks are also posted to our Telegram channel; its post time is one we cannot edit.
- After the matches: the nightly ledger. A snapshot of every settled pick goes to the public ledger on GitHub, so comparing two nights shows no earlier result changed. On its own it does not prove when a pick was made.
- Unchanged since that night: Bitcoin. Each snapshot is timestamped with OpenTimestamps, proving the file is unaltered since that night without trusting GitHub or us; nothing about when the picks were made.
The nightly snapshots run 24 June – 12 July 2026 (8 July missing); there are none from 13 July to 20 September 2026; since 21 September there is one every night. Picks settled in the gap are in every snapshot from 21 September, but their stamp only proves they have not changed since then. Removed picks, with the reason, are listed on the corrections page. The record is also JSON at /api/v1/track-record. Our software is private; the ledger, seals and JSON are enough to recompute every published figure.
What this is not. Not betting or financial advice, and not a promise of profit. Past results are real; most bettors still lose money.
Changes: 6 Oct 2026: match previews no longer show a confidence label; it was not based on data.
A question this page doesn’t answer? See the FAQ, open an issue on the public ledger, or message the Telegram channel.
Get the picks before kick-off
Free picks on Telegram